Amherst vs Middlebury

Amherst and Middlebury are both selective liberal arts colleges, with quantitative profiles and campus cultures that differ in ways that may matter to students and families.

By the numbers Amherst demonstrates stronger outcomes and value metrics. Its 10-year median earnings ($78k vs. $76k) are higher, achieved at a significantly lower average net price ($23k vs. $31k), resulting in a superior value multiplier (3.3× vs. 2.4× earnings per dollar of net price). Amherst also shows greater economic mobility (196% vs. 127%) and much lower admit-rate volatility (51% vs. 109%), suggesting more predictable selectivity. It is slightly more selective (9% vs. 11% acceptance) with a higher SAT 25-75th percentile range (1490–1580 vs. 1445–1550). Institutionally, Amherst scores higher on DOE financial health (2.8/3 vs. 2.4/3) and has a higher graduation rate (94% vs. 91%).

Where they overlap Both are selective liberal arts colleges with strong graduation rates and a focus on undergraduate education.

How they differ Culturally, Middlebury is often described as oriented around its Vermont setting and outdoor recreation. Amherst, while also in a New England location, leverages its membership in the Five College Consortium, which provides access to additional academic resources. The surrounding area of Amherst is generally perceived as more diverse.

Who each suits Amherst may suit a student prioritizing academic flexibility, access to a consortium's resources, and a focus on quantitative value. Middlebury may appeal to a student whose ideal college experience is closely tied to outdoor recreation and a campus community in a New England town.